Can I code this? A Two-Factor Authentication Service

Generating a time-based one-time code is a well-documented, simple algorithm. Being the trusted identity layer other applications rely on to keep their users' accounts secure is a different, much higher-stakes undertaking.

Just pay
Effort: not worth startingRunning cost: $0/mo to start

Why CanICodeThis says Just pay

  • Generating a TOTP (time-based one-time password) code from a shared secret follows a well-documented, open standard (RFC 6238)
  • For your own single app's login flow, adding TOTP-based 2FA using an established library is genuinely a reasonable weekend addition
  • Displaying a QR code for a user to scan into their own authenticator app is a solved, simple pattern

The parts that'll cause problems

  • Becoming a general-purpose 2FA PROVIDER that other applications integrate with and trust is a security-critical role — if your service has a flaw, every app that relies on it inherits the risk
  • Secure secret storage and recovery-code handling for account lockouts have a long history of subtle implementation mistakes even experienced teams make
  • This is a case where 'adding 2FA to my own app' (genuinely doable) and 'building a 2FA service for others to rely on' (genuinely not) are very different projects wearing the same name

How I'd build this

frontendNext.js
hostingVercel

MVP scope

  • If the real goal is securing your own app: add TOTP 2FA to your existing login using an established library, not from scratch

Postpone to v2

  • Becoming a 2FA provider for other applications (genuinely high-stakes security infrastructure — use an established provider like Okta or Twilio instead)

What it actually costs to build

AI agent — with a subscription (Claude Pro/Max, Cursor, etc.)$0 marginal
AI agent — pay-per-use API, no subscription$86–$172 one-time
Hosting, once it's running$0/mo (free tier)
Domain name, if you want your own~$12/yr

Existing tools solving a similar problem typically run $2.99–$2.99/mo — see how they compare below.

The build prompt

Don't build a general 2FA service for other apps to rely on. If you want two-factor authentication for your OWN app, add TOTP-based 2FA to your existing login flow using an established, well-audited library (implementing RFC 6238 yourself is exactly the kind of place small mistakes become real vulnerabilities) — that part is a genuinely reasonable, achievable addition.

← try another idea · browse the full register